Thursday, November 12, 2026

Not a business. Power to the people. UPDATE

 

Some members of the city council are making another run at knocking the mayor out of the city government game by trying to embed a highly paid administrator into our city charter. Apparently, having been elected to represent their constituents, they find that it's too hard and "inefficient," so they would rather hire someone else to run things. In fact, for some, this seems to have become their highest priority.

Has there been an overwhelming cry from city residents to spend $288,000 or so per year on yet another city employee while we are de-funding libraries, parks, transit and other public services; raising water, sewer, and other fees; and reducing services? 

No. There has not.

We keep hearing of the great benefits of an administrator without any real examples or evidence. Do cities with administrators have fewer budget problems, better public transportation, more public services, higher rates of citizen participation, lower poverty rates, happier children, or less crime? 

No one has brought forth any such examples or shown that similar benefits are not possible under a mayor-council system.
 
According to a recent La Crosse Tribune article about this issue, one city council member surveyed city employees to see which form of government they preferred. But we have seen no similar survey of voters. Or rather, the voters have said no twice already, through the actions of the elected council, but their preferences are being ignored. It's been a year-long constant battering ram against our mayor and our city. I guess no doesn't mean no to some.

What is the problem really? 

No one has actually defined the specific problems they feel an administrator would "solve." We keep hearing about dysfunction and inefficiency. Is such a drastic change in our basic form of government that will divert funds to yet another well-paid city employee the only solution? Could the mayor or council go through some training or therapy or something? Or could changes be made in personnel and other policies? Who knows? 

Possibly the council finds it inefficient to deal with people who don't agree with them. Maybe it would be more efficient for powerful interests to win over one unelected administrator than deal with 13 elected council members and a mayor. Maybe some people shouldn't be council members.

We elect the mayor and council to work together for the good of the city not palm the hard stuff off to an overseer. It's not an easy job and many of us couldn't handle it. So we don't run for office. To run for office and then say, "Well, this is too hard. We have to give up our control to a hired person and we have to bake it into our city charter to make sure no one can change this once we leave," is kind of hubris isn't it?
 
What if a bad administrator is hired? How will we get rid of her or him? At least if the mayor or council members ignore their constituents, we can vote them out of office. But an administrator can ignore at will, as we have seen, and there's no recourse for citizens except to complain to their elected officials who may not have any control either. Why would the council give up its and our power like this?

If we have an administrator, why would we need a mayor? if the mayor is just the city's spokesmodel, we might has well hold a lottery and rotate the ribbon cutting and proclamations and golden shovel moments to weekly community winners.

Proponents of changing our model of government give the impression that not having an administrator is an anomaly, but there are many examples, from Seattle to Chicago to New York City, where mayors and councils get things done without an administrator. People may vote for a mayor based on her or his platform or promises and hold them accountable by lobbying and voting.

We have long heard that governments should be run like businesses, but this is absurd. We are not clients or customers. We are self-governing citizens. The goal of a business is to make money. The goal of a government is to serve the self-governed. But how does a government run by an administrator measure success or failure? Often, it's all about the money and not about the service to or happiness of citizens. Things are efficient because it's the administrators making deals with the administrators. The messy citizens are out of the equation. Money and projects can flow smoothly whether they actually serve all the people or just those who have wealth, time, education, and experience enough to be included in the negotiations.

In an interview with Michael Podhorzer, Jason Stanley, author of  "How Fascism Works: The Politics of Us and Them," explained, "Democracy is about empowering the people who are less powerful. Democracy is about political equality. If an institution is responsible to money and not to people, it's not a democracy. Democracy is all about having systems and structures that empower powerless people to have an equal voice. The freedoms and rights of democracy are not about strengthening the positions of the powerful, they're about giving a voice to the voiceless."

Baking into our charter a hired, unelected administrator who is not directly accountable to the people and not able to be removed by a vote of the people will further erode the power and voices of the people. We should just say no to replacing democracy with administocracy. 
 

UPDATE: The council passed the legislation. Now, opponents will circulate a petition to force a referendum. Stay tuned for petition information.
 
### 

An election will be held in the City of La Crosse on Tuesday, April 6, 2027, to elect Council Members for Districts 1 through 6. If a primary election is necessary, it will take place on Tuesday, February 16, 2027.

The elected Council Members will serve four-year terms beginning April 20, 2027, and ending April 15, 2031.

Individuals interested in running for office may begin circulating nomination papers on December 1, 2026. All required candidacy documents must be filed with the City Clerk’s Office no later than 5:00 p.m. on Tuesday, January 5, 2027.

For additional information, including candidate requirements and downloadable candidacy forms and resources, visit the City of La Crosse's Candidate for Elected Office web page at https://www.cityoflacrosse.org/Your-Government/Departments/City-Clerk/Elections-and-Voting/Candidate-for-Elected



No comments:

Calendar